Arca Mail Backup vs. MailStore Home: an honest comparison
MailStore Home is a free, capable email archiver for Windows. Arca backs up automatically to mbox, plus NAS or S3 on Pro. Which one fits what you need.
- Published
- 5 min read
MailStore Home is a good pick if you want a free email archive on Windows that you run when it suits you and that can search inside attachments. Arca Mail Backup is the better fit if you want backups that run on their own in the background, saved as mbox files you can open without the app, and, on Pro, sent to a NAS or S3-compatible storage too. Both keep your mail on your own machine, and neither routes your messages through the vendor’s servers.
Facts checked in October 2026 against MailStore’s official website and help pages.
What MailStore Home is
MailStore Home is the free personal edition from MailStore Software GmbH, which makes email archiving software and now brands itself “MailStore by OpenText”. It has been around for a long time and is still actively maintained: version 26.3 shipped on July 8, 2026, according to its changelog.
According to MailStore’s own site:
- It’s free for private use at home. For businesses, the company sells MailStore Server instead.
- It runs on Windows 10 and Windows 11 and needs .NET Framework 4.8 or later. There’s no Mac or Linux version.
- It archives from IMAP and POP3 accounts (Gmail, Outlook.com, Yahoo and others), desktop Outlook, Exchange servers, Thunderbird and SeaMonkey, plus files such as PST and EML. Since version 25.2 it has an Outlook.com profile with OAuth sign-in.
- There’s a portable version that runs from a USB drive with no installation.
- Search covers the whole archive and, with optional iFilter packs, the text inside attachments.
- You can export messages to EML or MSG files, to an IMAP, Gmail or Exchange mailbox, or send them via SMTP to an address. That makes it handy for migrations as well.
- MailStore states that it has no access to your archived data.
These are real strengths. Its list of sources is broader than Arca’s (Arca doesn’t read PST files or archive from desktop Outlook or POP3). The portable version is great if you want to carry an archive on a thumb drive, and attachment search saves a lot of digging.
Where they differ
When the backup runs
In MailStore Home you start archiving yourself, with the profile’s Run button or a desktop shortcut, as its archiving help page describes. The help doesn’t mention any scheduling, and in a comment on MailStore’s own blog post about automated archiving, the MailStore team confirms that feature isn’t available in Home. Some users wire it up with Windows Task Scheduler, but that’s not something the vendor supports.
Arca backs up on its own, in the background: once a day on the free plan and every few hours on Pro. If a backup gets interrupted, it picks up where it left off. For backups this matters a lot. The one that depends on you remembering is the one that’s missing on the day you need it.
Format and where the archive lives
MailStore Home keeps its archive in its own data folder, which you locate from its administrative tools. The help pages don’t describe the file format; to get messages out for use elsewhere, you export them. Its backup and restore page says to close the app before copying that folder and warns that file hosting services like Dropbox aren’t suitable for backing up the archive.
Arca writes standard mbox, one file per folder and month, alongside a manifest.json, a copy of the SQLite index and a README that explains how to open everything. Thunderbird, Apple Mail or MBox Viewer Pro open those files directly, no export step needed. More on the format in What is an mbox file?
Destinations
MailStore Home archives to your computer’s drive or, with the portable version, to external media. Arca’s free plan backs up to an internal or external drive; Pro adds a NAS or S3-compatible storage (Wasabi, Backblaze B2, Cloudflare R2, Hetzner) and can write to several destinations at once. That’s how you get to the 3-2-1 rule without copying folders around by hand.
Restoring
MailStore Home gets messages back by exporting them to a mailbox or opening them in your mail client. Arca restores into the same account: messages come back into a new folder, nothing on the server is touched, and by default only what was deleted comes back, so you don’t get duplicates. Direct migration between connected accounts is coming soon to Arca Pro; MailStore Home can already move messages to another mailbox through export.
Side by side
| MailStore Home | Arca Mail Backup | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free for private use | Free for 1 account; Pro yearly from $8.99/yr or lifetime $44.99 (1 account) |
| Platforms | Windows 10 and 11 | Windows 10 (1809+) and 11; macOS 14+ |
| Sources | IMAP, POP3, Gmail, Outlook.com, Exchange, Outlook, Thunderbird, PST, EML… | IMAP: Gmail and Workspace, Outlook.com and Microsoft 365, any host; import .mbox (Takeout, Apple Mail, Thunderbird) |
| Automatic backups | Not in Home (run manually or via shortcut) | Yes, in the background (daily on Free, every few hours on Pro) |
| Format | MailStore data folder, read with the app; exports to EML/MSG | Standard mbox per folder and month + manifest.json |
| Destinations | Local drive or USB (portable) | Internal or external drive; NAS and S3-compatible on Pro |
| Attachment search | Yes, with optional iFilter packs | Searches subject, sender, recipient and text |
| Restore | Export to an IMAP, Gmail or Exchange mailbox | Restore into the same account, only deleted mail by default |
| Business use | No (that’s MailStore Server) | Pro levels from 1 to 100 accounts |
Arca’s US prices are shown before sales tax; the store shows your local price before you pay.
Which one should you use?
Go with MailStore Home if you’re on Windows, want something free with no stated account limit, have mail in desktop Outlook or PST files, or need to search inside attachments. If running the archive now and then is fine by you, it does the job very well.
Go with Arca if you want a backup that happens by itself, that any mbox reader can open ten years from now, and that can also land on a NAS or a cloud bucket. Or if you’re on a Mac, where MailStore Home doesn’t run.
You can also use both. They’re built for slightly different jobs: MailStore Home is first of all a searchable archive, Arca is an automatic backup in an open format.
How Arca handles it
Arca Mail Backup connects to your accounts over IMAP straight from your computer, with no server of ours in between, and keeps passwords in the Windows Credential Manager or the macOS Keychain. It backs up email only, not calendars or contacts. Mail deleted on the server stays in your backup, marked as deleted, so you can find it and put it back.
The Windows version is out now in the Microsoft Store, free for one account. The Mac version is in the Mac App Store. Arca Pro is on sale in both stores; plans are on the pricing page.