Private email backup with no server: why Arca doesn't have one
Arca Mail Backup has no server: your computer talks to your mail provider and writes to your own storage. What travels where, what doesn't, and the trade-offs.
- Published
- 4 min read
Arca Mail Backup has no server because the simplest way for us never to see your email is never to have it. The app runs entirely on your computer: it connects straight to your mail provider, writes the backup to the disk, NAS or bucket you choose, and keeps passwords in the Windows Credential Manager or the macOS Keychain. Your messages, passwords and backups never reach us, so we can’t read them, lose them or hand them over.
What “no server” means in practice
A lot of backup services work like this: you grant them access to your account, their servers read your mail and store it in their cloud. It’s convenient, and for some organisations it’s the right call. But it adds a third party with access to your entire mailbox.
Arca does the same job without the middleman. These are the only connections involved:
| Connection | What for | Who controls it |
|---|---|---|
| Your computer ↔ your mail provider | Reading messages over IMAP and, when you restore, putting them back | You, with your credentials |
| Your computer ↔ your destination (disk, NAS, S3) | Writing the backup | You, with your own keys |
| Your computer ↔ the store (Microsoft Store or Mac App Store) | Purchases and subscriptions | The store, under its own privacy policy |
There’s no fourth row with an Arca server in it. There’s no sign-up, no account with us, and no analytics in the app.
Passwords stay on your machine
Gmail and Google Workspace use an app password, stored in your system’s credential store. Outlook.com, Hotmail and Microsoft 365 use Sign in with Microsoft, on Microsoft’s own screen, and that sign-in also stays on your computer. Any other IMAP account’s server, username and password go to the same place.
Destinations work the same way. If you back up to Wasabi, Backblaze B2, Cloudflare R2 or Hetzner (on Pro), the access key is yours: you create it with your provider and can revoke it whenever you like. We never host a byte of your mail.
Logs don’t contain your email
Every app needs logs to diagnose problems. Arca’s never contain the content, subjects or addresses of your messages, and they only leave your computer if you export them and send them to us. If you contact support, we won’t ask for passwords or messages, because we never need them.
What you get
Nobody else holds a copy of your mailbox. When a cloud service has a breach, whatever it stored is exposed. There’s no store of ours to leak.
You know where every byte is. On a disk you can hold, on your NAS, or in a bucket in the region you picked. For a business that makes GDPR or vendor reviews simpler: the only provider holding your backup is the storage provider you chose (if you use S3), not an extra one added by the backup tool.
The format doesn’t lock you in. Backups are standard mbox files, one per folder and month, with a manifest.json, a copy of the SQLite index and a README explaining how to open everything without Arca. Thunderbird, Apple Mail and MBox Viewer Pro can read them. If you stop using Arca tomorrow, your backups are still there and still readable.
Stopping payment locks nothing. If a subscription lapses or you move down a level, backups already made are never locked or deleted. You can keep searching and restoring them.
What’s on you
Having no server has a less comfortable side too, and it’s fair to spell it out.
- The backup is wherever you put it. If you only back up to a disk in your computer and lose the computer, you lose the backup. That’s why a second destination away from home is worth having, as covered in the 3-2-1 backup rule for email.
- There’s no web dashboard. You can’t search your backup from your phone’s browser; search runs on your computer, over your copy.
- We can’t recover what we don’t have. If you lose access to your destination or your keys, there’s no spare copy on our side.
- Disk protection is up to you. Arca doesn’t encrypt the working copy it keeps on your computer. That’s what BitLocker on Windows and FileVault on the Mac are for.
About encryption
Encryption is a Pro option in Arca, on Mac and Windows, since version 1.1.0. Files are encrypted with age, an open standard, before they leave your computer, and either your device key or a recovery key that only you hold opens them, with Arca or with the age tool. If you don’t turn it on and you use an S3 bucket, your provider’s encryption at rest and access controls are your first line.
The website follows the same rule
arcamailbackup.com sets no cookies and runs no analytics or tracking. The only personal data we get is what you send us through the contact form or by email. The details are in our privacy policy.
Trying it
Arca Mail Backup backs up Gmail, Outlook and any IMAP account to mbox files that belong to you. It’s free for one account on a disk of your computer; Pro adds NAS, S3-compatible storage and more accounts, from $8.99 a year (see pricing). It’s in the Microsoft Store for Windows and the Mac App Store for Mac, with Arca Pro on sale in both.