How to test your email backup (and know it really works)
A backup you've never restored is a guess. How to run a restore drill, open the mbox files without the app and check them against manifest.json, step by step.
- Published
- 5 min read
The only way to know an email backup works is to get something back out of it. A “completed” entry in the history means the app finished, not that you can open what it saved. Three checks, about half an hour in total, will tell you: a restore drill with a test message, opening one of the files in a different app, and confirming that what’s on your destination matches its manifest.
Why bother
Backups fail quietly more often than you’d think. An external drive that was unplugged weeks ago, a password that expired, a bucket key someone revoked, a folder that dropped out of the selection. If you don’t look, you find out on the day you need one particular message.
Businesses have a formal reason too: Article 32 of the GDPR expects the ability to restore personal data after an incident, and a process for regularly testing that your measures work. We went into this in how long to keep business email.
Check 1: look at the status, then verify
Start with the easy part.
- Open each account’s page in Arca and look at the latest backups. They should be completed and recent.
- Make sure each account goes to the destinations you think it does. Every account picks its own, and it’s easy to add a new account and forget the NAS.
- Run a verification. Arca checks the backup against what it saved and tells you if anything doesn’t match. It’s included in the free plan, and you can run it whenever you like.
If anything shows up red, fix it before going on. There’s no point drilling a restore on a backup you already know is broken.
Check 2: a restore drill
This is where you find out whether you can actually get a deleted message back. Use a test message, not an important one.
- Send an email to the account you want to test, with a subject that’s easy to search for, like “restore test” plus today’s date.
- In Arca, click Back Up Now and wait for it to finish.
- In your mail (Gmail, Outlook, your host’s webmail), delete that message and empty the trash.
- Back in Arca, click Back Up Now again so it notices the deletion.
- Search for the subject. The message should be marked “Deleted on server”.
- Restore it. Arca puts it into a new folder called “Restored Arca” plus the date, without touching anything already on the server. By default only what was deleted comes back, so you won’t fill your mailbox with duplicates.
- Open your mail and check the message is in that folder, with its attachment if it had one.
If you just want the single message, you can also save it to a separate file from the search, without restoring it.
Run this drill for at least one account of each type you use (Gmail, Microsoft 365, hosting), because every provider behaves a little differently.
Check 3: open the backup without Arca
A backup in an open format should be readable without the app that made it. If Arca were gone one day, your email should still be yours.
On each destination, Arca leaves a layout like this:
arca/my-computer/
├── README.txt
├── manifest.json
├── index.sqlite.zst
└── accounts/
└── ana-gmail-com/
└── folders/
├── all-mail/2026/
│ ├── 2026-09.mbox
│ └── 2026-10.mbox
└── trash/2026/
└── 2026-10.mbox
- Copy the mbox of a closed month (not the current one) to another folder. Always work on a copy, never on the original in your destination.
- Open it with whatever you have:
- Apple Mail: File > Import Mailboxes > Files in mbox format. Messages land in a mailbox called Import, which you can delete afterwards.
- Thunderbird: with the ImportExportTools NG add-on.
- MBox Viewer Pro: opens it directly.
- Look for a couple of messages you remember from that month, open one with an attachment, and check the attachment opens.
One thing to know: the mbox stores the messages, but it doesn’t know which ones were later deleted on the server. That state lives in Arca’s index. Open the mbox in another app and you’ll also see messages that are no longer in your mailbox, unmarked.
Each destination’s README.txt explains all of this, including how to open everything without the app. Read it once now; it’s what you’ll need on the day you’re in a hurry.
Check 4: match the manifest.json
manifest.json is a text file that lists every file on the destination with its size, its SHA-256 hash, how many messages it holds and whether the month is closed. It lets you confirm, without Arca, that what’s on the destination is intact.
-
Open
manifest.jsonin any text editor and find the file you copied (for example,2026/2026-09.mbox). Note itssha256andmessages. -
Hash the file:
- Mac, in Terminal:
shasum -a 256 2026-09.mbox - Windows, in PowerShell:
Get-FileHash .\2026-09.mbox(Windows prints it in uppercase; ignore case when comparing)
- Mac, in Terminal:
-
The two hashes must be identical. If they aren’t, the file on the destination has changed or is damaged.
-
Count the messages. Each message in an mbox starts with a
Fromline, so:- Mac:
grep -c '^From ' 2026-09.mbox - Windows:
(Select-String -Path .\2026-09.mbox -Pattern '^From ' -CaseSensitive).Count
The number should match
messages. - Mac:
Use a closed month. The current month’s file is rewritten with each backup and may not match if you catch it mid-run.
How often
- Every few months: the restore drill on one account.
- After any change: a new password, a new destination, a new provider, a new disk.
- Once a year: the full set, opening without Arca and matching the manifest on every destination.
Put it in your calendar. The backups nobody checks are the ones that fail without anyone noticing.
How Arca helps
Arca Mail Backup stores mail as standard mbox, one file per folder and month, with a manifest.json and a README on every destination, so you never need the app to read anything. Search, verification and restoring into the same account are all in the free plan, so you can run every check here without paying. Pro adds NAS, S3-compatible storage and several destinations at once (see pricing), and verification reports are coming soon.
On Windows it’s out now in the Microsoft Store. On Mac, it’s in the Mac App Store.