Skip to content
Arca Mail Backup

Blog

Is Thunderbird a good email backup? What it does and doesn't

Thunderbird keeps a local copy of your IMAP mail, but it syncs deletions too. What it really protects you from, what it doesn't, and how to use it well.

  • Published
  • 4 min read

Thunderbird is half a backup. With an IMAP account it downloads a local copy of your messages, which helps if the server goes down or you’re offline. But that copy is a mirror: when a message is deleted on the server, Thunderbird deletes it from your computer on the next sync. To be protected from deletions, account takeovers or a closed account, you need something more.

Thunderbird is a good program. It’s free and open source, runs on Windows, macOS and Linux, and plenty of people have used it for years. So it’s natural to assume that if all your mail is downloaded, you’re covered. Let’s see how far that holds.

What Thunderbird does

It keeps your messages on your drive

For IMAP accounts, Thunderbird downloads local copies of your messages by default. You’ll find the setting in the account’s Synchronization & Storage section, as the option to keep messages for the account on this computer. The Advanced button lets you choose which folders are kept.

That’s what lets you read and search offline, and if the server has a bad day, your mail is still right there.

It uses an open format

By default Thunderbird stores each folder as a single mbox file (shown in its settings as “File per folder”). There’s an alternative, maildir, with one file per message, but it only applies to new accounts and isn’t the default. Mbox is an open format that lots of programs read, so those files aren’t locked into Thunderbird. More in What is an mbox file?

It can export your profile

Thunderbird has a tool that exports your whole profile (accounts, messages, address books and settings) to a zip file, which you bring back in with its Import tool. For large profiles, the fallback is to copy the profile folder by hand while Thunderbird is closed.

It has Local Folders

Local Folders aren’t tied to any server. Move or copy messages there and they stay, even if they disappear from the server. That’s the classic way to archive with Thunderbird.

What Thunderbird doesn’t do

It doesn’t protect you from deletions

IMAP is designed so every device sees the same mailbox. Delete an email on your phone and it’s gone from the server, and Thunderbird removes it from its copy too. Someone breaks into your account and empties your inbox: same thing. And when Trash empties itself after 30 days, as it does in Gmail and Outlook.com, it’s gone from your local copy as well.

This is the crux. Thunderbird’s local copy protects you if the server fails, not if someone (you included) deletes something.

It doesn’t back itself up

Thunderbird stores your messages in a folder on your drive, and that’s it. If the drive dies, the laptop is stolen or ransomware encrypts your files, the local copy goes with them. To count as a backup, that folder needs to be copied somewhere else, and setting that up is on you.

It doesn’t remember for you

Local Folders and profile export both work, but they’re manual. You have to remember to move messages or export every so often. In practice, the last export is usually months old.

Copying a live profile is risky

If you copy the profile folder while Thunderbird is running, you can end up with half-written files. Close it first.

Getting more out of it if you already use it

If Thunderbird is already your daily mail app, you can make it a better safety net:

  1. Keep local copies of every folder you care about, in the account’s synchronization settings.
  2. Archive important mail into Local Folders now and then, especially before emptying Trash or doing a clean-up.
  3. Copy the profile folder to an external drive with Thunderbird closed, or use the profile export.
  4. Keep one of those copies off-site to follow the 3-2-1 rule.
  5. Test now and then that the copy actually opens.

It works, but it’s a lot of manual steps. If you want a backup that runs by itself and doesn’t follow the server’s deletions, use a tool built for that.

You don’t have to choose

You can keep reading your mail in Thunderbird and run a separate automatic backup. They do different jobs: Thunderbird is your mail client, with its local cache, and the backup is where you go when something has disappeared.

How Arca handles it

Arca Mail Backup connects to your accounts over IMAP (Gmail, Outlook.com, Microsoft 365 or your web host) and backs them up on its own, in the background. Unlike a mail client, it doesn’t mirror deletions: whatever disappears from the server stays in your backup, marked as deleted, and you can restore it into the same account in a new folder. Backups are standard mbox files, one per folder and month, which Thunderbird can open too.

If you have older mail in Thunderbird, say in Local Folders, Arca can import those mbox files for free as an offline account that you can search and restore into a connected account. Imported accounts don’t count toward your plan’s limit.

The free plan covers one account backed up to a drive on your computer. Pro adds more accounts, backups every few hours, and NAS and S3 destinations, from $8.99 a year (see pricing). Arca for Windows is in the Microsoft Store and the Mac version in the Mac App Store, with Arca Pro on sale in both.

All posts

Mac, Windows and Linux

Start with one account, free.

Get Arca Mail Backup from the Mac App Store or the Microsoft Store, or download the direct version from this site, which is also the one for Linux. It's free for one account, and Arca Pro adds more accounts, NAS and S3 storage.

All downloads

Arca Pro bought in a store doesn't unlock the direct version, and the other way round. Why