Skip to content
Arca Mail Backup

Blog

Open vs. proprietary formats: where your email backup stands in 10 years

An email backup in a proprietary format depends on its vendor and app still being around. What can go wrong in ten years, and how to check portability yourself.

  • Published
  • 8 min read

An email backup in an open format is one you’ll be able to open ten years from now with whatever program you have on hand. A backup in a proprietary format depends on the vendor, its license and its app still working on the computer you’ll have then. That doesn’t make it a bad backup, but it does make it one with a dependency worth knowing about, and checking, before you trust it with fifteen years of mail.

Facts checked in October 2026 against Mail Backup X’s official website and documentation from Microsoft and Apple.

What open and proprietary actually mean

A format is open when anyone can find out how it’s built and write a program that reads it, without asking anyone’s permission. mbox, EML and Maildir are open: dozens of programs read them, free and paid, on every operating system. If you’re curious what an mbox file looks like inside, see What is an mbox file?

A format is proprietary when a company defines it for its own product and either doesn’t publish how it works, or publishes it but only its own program reads it well. The backup exists, takes up space on your drive and is complete, but to see what’s in it you need the app that wrote it.

You don’t notice the difference on day one. You notice it when something around the backup changes.

What can happen in ten years

You keep an email backup for the bad day: a closed account, a mass deletion, an audit, a lawsuit. That day might come next week or next decade. Over ten years, things like these happen.

The vendor shuts down or gets acquired

Software companies change hands all the time. Sometimes nothing changes: MailStore, which now brands itself “MailStore by OpenText”, keeps shipping new versions of MailStore Home as usual. Other times the product gets folded into something else, renamed, or no longer sold to individuals. If your backup can only be read by that app, its future rests on decisions you don’t get to make.

You stop paying for maintenance

Plenty of backup programs are a one-time purchase that includes a year of updates. After that year, the program keeps working but stops getting changes. As long as your system stays the same, that’s fine. The trouble starts when the system moves on and your copy of the program doesn’t.

The app won’t run on your new system

This isn’t hypothetical. In 2018 Apple announced that macOS Mojave would be the last version to run 32-bit apps, and starting with macOS Catalina they stopped working. Anyone with data in a format only one of those apps could read had to find a new version, keep an old computer around, or convert the data in time.

With an open format, losing the original app is an inconvenience. With a proprietary one, it can lock you out of your backup.

The compression or encryption is vendor-specific

Compressing and encrypting a backup are both good ideas. The risk comes when the way it’s done is the vendor’s own: a compression algorithm only that program implements, or encryption in an unpublished file format. When a website says “AES-256”, that tells you the algorithm, not the container. To open the file you also need to know how the key, the parameters and the data are stored. If only the program knows that, only the program can decrypt it.

Published encryption standards solve this. OpenPGP is an IETF RFC, and age has a public specification with several independent implementations. A file encrypted with either one opens with any compatible tool, as long as you have the key.

The only way out is through the app

Many programs with their own format can export to mbox, EML or PST. That’s a real way out, and it’s good that it exists. But as long as you rely on it, exporting is a step you can only take with the program installed, the license in order, and a system it runs on. If any of those three fails one day, the door closes.

A concrete example: Mail Backup X

Mail Backup X from InventPure is a full-featured tool for Windows and Mac that backs up IMAP accounts and mail from desktop clients. Its website promises “highly compressed archives” that let you “Save up to 3X Storage space”. It describes an “Ultra High Compression algorithm with repair recovery records” and lets you encrypt the backup: “Encrypt your data with your private key”. To read it, there’s an “inbuilt archive file viewer”, and to get mail out, it exports to .mbox, .eml, .pst, .olm and .rge.

Those are real benefits: the backup takes less space, copes better with a damaged disk, and nobody without your key can read it. The site is refreshingly upfront about the trade-off, too: “If you lose or forget the personal key, even we won’t be able to decrypt the data for you.”

What the site doesn’t document is the archive’s internal format. So in practice, opening the backup means using Mail Backup X. According to its store page, a purchase includes a year of updates, and after that, maintenance is an optional $20 a year. Its changelog lists version 2.0.26130 from May 12, 2026; the one before, 2.0.25232, is from August 22, 2025, and the one before that, 2.0.23108, from April 30, 2023.

None of this suggests the program is abandoned or insecure. It points to a dependency: ten years from now, reading that backup requires Mail Backup X to still exist and run on your system, or for you to have exported to mbox in time. If you use it, the fix is simple: export to mbox every so often and keep that export next to the backup.

Proprietary formats exist for good reasons

It would be unfair to paint proprietary formats as a whim. They exist because they solve problems a plain mbox file doesn’t:

  • Compression. Email is text and attachments are base64-encoded, so it compresses very well. A custom archive can compress message by message and still let you open each one.
  • Fast search. An indexed database searches millions of messages in a moment. Scanning a multi-gigabyte mbox file for a subject line is much slower.
  • Deduplication. If the same attachment shows up in fifty emails, a custom format can store it once.
  • Metadata. Labels, read status and source folders fit more naturally in a database than in a text file.

And proprietary doesn’t always mean closed. Outlook’s PST belongs to Microsoft, yet Microsoft publishes the full specification, [MS-PST]. Anyone can read it and write a reader. The catch is that it’s a complex format built around Outlook, and few programs outside Outlook read it as well. Documented and easy to read aren’t the same thing. There’s more on that in Back Up Outlook.com and Microsoft 365 Without PST Files.

The useful question isn’t whether a format is open or proprietary. It’s whether you can read your backup without the vendor’s help.

How to check portability yourself

You don’t have to take anyone’s website at its word, ours included. With your backup in front of you, run through these:

  1. Can you open it today with a different program? Copy one file from the backup to another computer that doesn’t have the tool installed, and try opening it with Thunderbird, Apple Mail or an mbox viewer. If it opens, you’re in good shape. If you have to export first, note that dependency.
  2. Is the format documented? Look on the vendor’s site for a specification of the file itself, not a list of export formats. If there isn’t one, only the program knows the format.
  3. Is the encryption a published standard? Ask what it’s encrypted with and whether another tool can decrypt it with your key. “Military-grade encryption” doesn’t answer that.
  4. What happens if you don’t renew? Read what the license covers once maintenance ends, and whether the backup stays accessible.
  5. Can you check it’s complete without the app? A list of files with their sizes and fingerprints (hashes) lets you verify it with ordinary tools.

If the answer to the first question is no, you don’t need to switch tools tomorrow. Just add a second copy in an open format, which is what the 3-2-1 rule asks for anyway. For the other checks, there’s a step-by-step guide in How to test your email backup.

Question Open format (mbox, EML) Undocumented proprietary format
Opens without the app that made it? Yes Usually not
Can be verified with ordinary tools? Yes Only from the app
What if the app goes away? Open the backup with another program Depends on having exported first
Compression and search More limited in the file itself; a separate index makes up for it Usually better
Encryption With a published standard, if encrypted Up to the vendor

How Arca does it, and what you’d lose if Arca disappeared tomorrow

Arca Mail Backup saves mail as standard mbox, one file per folder and month. Each message is stored exactly as it came from the server, and Arca adds a few headers of its own at the top (starting with X-Arca-) with the source folder, read status and, for Gmail, labels. Any mail program treats them as ordinary headers.

Alongside the mbox files, every backup includes:

  • A manifest.json, a text file listing each mbox with its size, message count and SHA-256 fingerprint. You can use it to check the backup is complete without opening Arca.
  • A copy of the SQLite index, compressed. It’s a convenience for fast search. If it’s lost, your mail is still all there in the mbox files, and SQLite is itself an open format that plenty of tools read.
  • A README explaining how to open the files with Thunderbird, Apple Mail or MBox Viewer Pro, our own mbox viewer.

Arca has no servers of its own: it connects to your mail over IMAP from your computer and writes to the drive, NAS or bucket you choose. There’s no Arca cloud account where your backup lives.

So what would you lose if Arca disappeared tomorrow? Automatic backups, search and restoring to your account. And from the backup itself? Nothing. The files are already on your storage, in a format read by programs that have nothing to do with us. One honest caveat: Arca doesn’t encrypt the backup today, so the drive or bucket you keep it on should be encrypted (FileVault, BitLocker or your storage provider’s encryption).

Arca is free for one account backed up to a drive on your computer. On Windows it’s in the Microsoft Store, and on Mac in the Mac App Store. Pro plans are on the pricing page.

All posts

Mac, Windows and Linux

Start with one account, free.

Get Arca Mail Backup from the Mac App Store or the Microsoft Store, or download the direct version from this site, which is also the one for Linux. It's free for one account, and Arca Pro adds more accounts, NAS and S3 storage.

All downloads

Arca Pro bought in a store doesn't unlock the direct version, and the other way round. Why